GoogleTranslate Service


What’s wrong with e-learning?

December 13th, 2010 by Graham Attwell
Clive Shepherd’s realistic if depressing litany of the failure if much of the online learning provision today. It follows on the publication of the Towards Maturity 2010 Benchmark Report (http://www.towardsmaturity.org/2010benchmark) which suggests that face-to-face classroom courses are being converted lock, stock and barrel into self-paced, self-directed, online courses as a panic solution to a lack of funds..
clipped from onlignment.com
  • It fails to engage and inspire.
  • It is over-long and information heavy.
  • It is insufficiently relevant to employees’ jobs.
  • It provides inadequate opportunities for collaboration with peers.
  • It fails to provide the learner with opportunities for personal support.
  • In the way it is applied, it repeats many of the mistakes of the classroom courses it replaces, particularly when it is used primarily for sheep dipping and compliance. We need less courses and more resources.
  • It is designed and developed without consultation with learners or learners’ managers and is not continuously enhanced and improved in response to feedback from these stakeholders.
  • At a time when there are so many interesting ways in which online media can be employed (as video, podcasts, mobile apps, 3D environments, games and sims), it remains dull and uni-dimensional.
  •   blog it

    Leave a Reply

    Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree Plugin

    • Search Pontydysgu.org

      News Bites

      MOOCs and beyond

      A special issue of the online journal eLearning Papers has been released entitled MOOCs and beyond. Editors Yishay Mor and Tapio Koshkinen say the issue brings together in-depth research and examples from the field to generate debate within this emerging research area.

      They continue: “Many of us seem to believe that MOOCs are finally delivering some of the technology-enabled change in education that we have been waiting nearly two decades for.

      This issue aims to shed light on the way MOOCs affect education institutions and learners. Which teaching and learning strategies can be used to improve the MOOC learning experience? How do MOOCs fit into today’s pedagogical landscape; and could they provide a viable model for developing countries?

      We must also look closely at their potential impact on education structures. With the expansion of xMOOC platforms connected to different university networks—like Coursera, Udacity, edX, or the newly launched European Futurelearn—a central question is: what is their role in the education system and especially in higher education?”


      The cost of austerity and privatisation

      There is growing concern over the consequences of the English (Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have different policies) government’s cutbacks and privatisation of  careers guidance for young people. The International Centre for Guidance Studies reports on a discussion paper called ‘Cost to the Economy of Government Policy on Career Guidance: A Business Case for Funding and Strengthening Career Guidance in Schools‘ from Lizzie Taylor who is an Careers England Affiliate Member. “The report claims that the economic consequence of current government policy on career education is an escalating annual cost to young people in reduced and lost earnings, reaching £676m p.a. in 2018 before dropping back slightly to £665 m p.a.2022. The total cost in reduced and lost earnings to young people in the period 2013 to 2022 is estimated as £3.2bn.”


      Open Education 2030

      The Institute for Prospective Technological Studies (IPTS) –part of the Joint Research Center of the European commission –  is calling upon experts and practitioners to come up with visionary papers and imaginative scenarios on how Open Education in 2030 in Europe might look with a major focus on Open Educational Resources and Practices, in different education sectors.

      The foresight scenarios submitted can be normative or descriptive, idealistic or provocative, critical or imaginary, reflective or polemic, imaginative or concrete, comprehensive or selective, general or specific. They should be both inspiring and scientifically sound.

      Submissions are free to choose any angle, subject, approach, but they say the future vision and/or scenario should address the key question of how Open Education in 2030 in Europe might look, and include the role of OER.

      More details from the EU Europa website.


      PLE Conference Update

      I wasn’t overoptimistic about the Personal Learning Environments Conference this year. Discussions about PLEs have been subsumed in the hype over MOOCs. And most conferences are struggling with the ongoing recession. But I am delighted that we have received 59 submissions including a number of great proposals for interactive workshops.

      The PLE Conference takes place on 10 and 12 July in Berlin.


      Twitter

      Follow Graham Attwell on Twitter Follow Cristina Costa on Twitter Follow Dirk Stieglitz on Twitter

      Other Pontydysgu Spaces

    • Sounds of the Bazaar AudioBoo

    • Recent Posts

    • Archives

    • Meta

    • Upcoming Events

        There are no events.
    • Categories